The New York Yankees in June – Part One – The Batters (2021)

The New York Yankees were a mess in June. You don’t have to take my word – no less luminaries than Brian Cashman and Giancarlo Stanton agree with me and the language they used was far less kind than mine.

Their record for the month was 12 wins and 14 losses. They lost 5 of the last 6 games in the month. At one point, they lost 7 of 9.

Their roster is full of batters who hover around the Mendoza line (.200). There are others who appear way beyond their sell-by date. Let’s survey the team’s performance on the month:

We’ll begin with the individual record of the batters:

Gio Urshela 3B2394142851580329.298.327.532.858
DJ LeMahieu if2611312335041901012.292.350.442.792
Gary Sanchez c248315247081901125,289.372.6631.035
Giancarlo Stanton DH247610221051501923.289.427.500.927
Miguel Andujar lf/3B2378132110590611.269.318.474.792
Aaron Judge rf 249417244051301530.255.358.457.815
Rougned Odor 2B185971440350217.237.274.458.732
Brett Gardner LF/CF2453912313811614.226.394.491.885
Gleyber Torres ss2590819301721124.
Luke Voit 1B9385811240213.211.250.447.697
Kyle Higashioka c819240011006.211.211.368.579
Clint Frazier lf2251710401801323.196.379.333.712
Tyler Wade if/of1913720001223.
Chris Gittens 1b1021120014039.
Luis Cessa p10000000000.
Mike Ford 1B13000000003.
Nestor Cortes p11000000000.
Lucas Luetge p10000000000.
Aroldis Chapman p10000000000.
Wandy Peralta p20000000000.
Chad Green p10000000000.
Zack Britton p10000000000.
Domingo German p 11000000001.
Jonathan Loaisiga p10000000000.
Jameson Taillon 10000000000.
New York Yankees – batters and hitters June 2021 in order of batting average


In April, Gary Sanchez seemed to have lost his role has the first choice starter behind the plate for the New York club. In May, Kyle Higashioka, whilst still stronger defensively wiped-out with the bat and his average crumbled. In June, one of the few bright lights was that offensively, at least, Sanchez put his game back together. He led the team in OPS and Home Runs and the fact that he was third on the month in batting average was a massive change. Higashioka remains Gerrit Cole’s catcher of choice but his batting performance disintegrated and at the moment, I would guess this is his last season in the pinstripes.


On the 17th of June, first baseman and sometime designated hitter, Mike Ford who had been having a terrible season and had cleared waivers, was traded to Tampa Bay for those old friends a “player to be named later” and “cash considerations”. With Luke Voit out injured yet again, the Yankees called up Chris Gittens and he had his chance to impress. Gittens is a so-so defensive first baseman but has been proving himself as a capable slugger at Scranton/Wilkes-Barre Railriders (Triple-A) and now had his opportunity to prove he could deal with major league pitching in the same manner. Regrettably, it didn’t work out that way. He batted .095 (2 hits) and achieved his first home run in the top flight but no more. Once the Yankees knew that Luke Voit was on his way back then they reassigned Gittens (on the 21st) and the regular 1st baseman was added to the active roster the following day. In the 8 games he played, Luke did a little better than he had between his first and second spells on the injured list, batting .211 and achieving four extra base hits in quick style. The Yankees will hold Gittens in reserve and given Voit’s predilection for injuries,his time may come again.

The Yankees’ other firstbase option remains DJ Lemahieu who is still constantly switched between first base, his usual second base home and third base. If the changes in his defensive role was the thing that has unsettled his batting performance then he seems to be growing into it because in June he looked far more like the hitter he had been in 2019 and 2020. He batted .292 with 9 extra base hits on the month. However, the Yankees must be running out of justifications for keeping inserting Rougned Odor in the second base slot. Although, at first glance of our table he seems reasonably well-situated that is only because there is a chasm in the middle of the table which reveals that there are more than 50 batting average points between LeMahieu’s June performance and Odor’s. Odor still gives the Yankees some slugging power but there is little else to recommend him.

Third base is very much the possession of Gio Urshela, who sits at the head of our table for June. He also brings some power – he is second only to Sanchez in extra base hits in June. His weakness? His patience at the plate. 3 walks compared to 29 strike outs in June. Odor is pretty awful in that category too – 2 walks and 17 strikeouts. Because Urshela is great at hitting for average, he is well ahead of Odor in on-base percentage. Nothing much to adore about Odor indeed. At least Texas are still paying most of his salary.

What should the Yankees do at shortstop? Gleyber Torres, the incumbent, continues to struggle defensively and offensively. There is no question they must upgrade somewhere before the trading deadline, if they want to make the playoffs. The obvious thing to do would be to look to improve at shortstop, centrefield and bring in a new starting pitcher. If they’re going to do that then some sacrifices must be made but I really can’t figure who their trading chips are who would go in the opposite direction. The Yankees have a weak hand at the major league level and unless they are prepared to give up a substantial amount of propsects, I don’t know what their solution is.


And if the Yankees infield is under-performing let us swiftly say the same about the outfield. Aaron Hicks is gone for the season and has been a disaster since the Yankees signed him to a contract which guarantees him $10.5M p.a. from 2020-23 and a contract which runs through to 2025 at least. The senior hitter on the team, Brett Gardner (turning 38 years very soon and being paid less than half of Hicks annual salary) has therefore been pressed into action pretty much every day and it is not going well. June was a little better for him but he still only managed a .226 batting average. He has managed a little more in the power-hitting part of his game but it really would have been better for him to have retired at the end of last season. Aaron Judge‘s performance dipped slightly but his .255 batting average, 5 home runs and 4 doubles still made him a very important part of the team especially whilst so many around him were struggling.

Miguel Andujar has found his time in the line-up increase with the poor form of Clint Frazier and now whilst he is unlikely to ever see regular playing time again at third base which was his previous home, his work at leftfield has given him an opportunity to regain his previous form with the bat where he, like Judge, contributed 5 home runs in June. By comparison, Frazier’s .196 batting average and one home run makes me wonder almost everyday why the Yankees persist with this player who presents more flash and panache with his tongue than he ever does with his bat.

Like Gittens, Ryan LaMarre was a failed experiment during the short period he was promoted to fill a gap and his time on the 40-man roster came to a brief and unspectacular end.

Designated Hitter

GianCarlo Stanton joined the two aforementioned players in adding 5 home runs to the month’s total. Aaron Boone has not risked him in an outfield position despite all the deadwood the team seems to be carrying, which speaks volumes about his vulnerability to injury. His form has been solid or above and he is a player that the Yankees cannot afford to lose.

New York Yankees – 5 best batters in June 2021 – Rated 1-5 – LtoR: Gary Sanchez, Gio Urshela,
DJ LeMahieu, GianCarlo Stanton, Aaron Judge

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.